SB827: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
imported>Rihallix
(Improved wording of summary. Noted that Sasha Aickin's map is unofficial, added his disclaimer. Corrected Goodman > Goodmon and added his title.)
imported>Rihallix
(added citations and links to health issues of locating housing near transit corridors/major roads)
Line 55: Line 55:
=== Concerns and involvement of local resident stakeholders could be overridden ===
=== Concerns and involvement of local resident stakeholders could be overridden ===


Richard Hall‏&nbsp; @rihallix&nbsp; [https://twitter.com/rihallix/status/949786475071094784 3:35 PM - 6 Jan 2018] from San Rafael, CA<br/> Replying to @TaupeAvenger<br/> "The community no longer has a say. #sb827 forces zoning changes by state fiat. With #sb35 passed all voices of resident stakeholders, councils, mayors are forcibly suppressed. Developers take control."
Richard Hall‏&nbsp; @rihallix&nbsp; [https://twitter.com/rihallix/status/949786475071094784 3:35 PM - 6 Jan 2018]&nbsp;, an advocate for sensible growth who has a blog [[Www.planningforreality.org|www.planningforreality.org]] from San Rafael, CA<br/> Replying to @TaupeAvenger<br/> "The community no longer has a say. #sb827 forces zoning changes by state fiat. With #sb35 passed all voices of resident stakeholders, councils, mayors are forcibly suppressed. Developers take control."


@Hyper_lexic<br/> "I think it might go too far in the reach - minimum 45’ zoning on current residential side streets would be a real shock."
@Hyper_lexic<br/> "I think it might go too far in the reach - minimum 45’ zoning on current residential side streets would be a real shock."
Line 181: Line 181:
=== <br/> This would concentrate new housing next to health hazards from traffic ===
=== <br/> This would concentrate new housing next to health hazards from traffic ===


This puts dense housing next to&nbsp;<br/> Richard Hall @rihallix&nbsp;Jan 6<br/> Replying to @MarketUrbanism @TaupeAvenger<br/> When #sb827 dictates upzoning by fiat within 1/2 mile of transit corridors that maps to freeways and arterials. Here’s your data showing how that doubles autism rates:&nbsp;<br/> [http://articles.latimes.com/2010/dec/16/health/la-he-autism-20101217 http://articles.latimes.com/2010/dec/16/health/la-he-autism-20101217].
This puts dense housing next to&nbsp;<br/> Richard Hall @rihallix&nbsp;Jan 6<br/> Replying to @MarketUrbanism @TaupeAvenger<br/> <br/> "When #sb827 dictates upzoning by fiat within 1/2 mile of transit corridors that maps to freeways and arterials. Here’s your data showing how that doubles autism rates:&nbsp;<br/> [http://articles.latimes.com/2010/dec/16/health/la-he-autism-20101217 http://articles.latimes.com/2010/dec/16/health/la-he-autism-20101217]."


Other articles citing health issues that would be exacerbated by SB827
&nbsp;

World Health Organization: Health Effects of Transport Related Air Pollution, 2005 states:
<blockquote>"There is evidence that implicates ambient air pollution in adverse effects on pregnancy, birth outcomes and male fertility. Modelled studies on exposure to traffic-related air pollutants suggest that they are a risk factor for adverse birth outcomes."</blockquote>
[[http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74715/E86650.pdf http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74715/E86650.pdf]

[http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74715/E86650.pdf http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74715/E86650.pdf]]
CNN:&nbsp;locating housing near transit corridors increase dementia risk, study says,&nbsp;January 4, 2017
[http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/04/health/dementia-risk-living-near-major-road/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/04/health/dementia-risk-living-near-major-road/index.html]

American Heart Association:&nbsp;Homes near highways may up heart disease risks, Oct 2014<br/> [https://news.heart.org/homes-near-highways-may-up-heart-disease-risks/ https://news.heart.org/homes-near-highways-may-up-heart-disease-risks/]


=== Liquefaction and earthquake risk since the transit areas tend to be closer to the Bay ===
=== Liquefaction and earthquake risk since the transit areas tend to be closer to the Bay ===
Line 266: Line 277:


matthewplan @matthewplan<br/> Replying to @YIMBYwiki @housingforla and 2 others<br/> "6) maybe bring down heights 10 ft but provide this 10 extra height to 100% affordable projects or housing cooperatives."
matthewplan @matthewplan<br/> Replying to @YIMBYwiki @housingforla and 2 others<br/> "6) maybe bring down heights 10 ft but provide this 10 extra height to 100% affordable projects or housing cooperatives."

&nbsp;


=== Exclude rent-controlled units ===
=== Exclude rent-controlled units ===

&nbsp;

&nbsp;


&nbsp;
&nbsp;
Line 279: Line 284:
== Advocacy strategies ==
== Advocacy strategies ==


<br/> Robert Collier @rcollier&nbsp;Jan 6<br/> Retweeted Brian Hanlon&nbsp;<br/> "#SB827 is political suicide because it gives opponents and Republicans ample reason to tar this bill and #smartgrowth as a wholesale attack on neighborhood character, democratic local decisionmaking and quality of life."
<br/> Robert Collier @rcollier&nbsp;Jan 6<br/> Retweeted Brian Hanlon&nbsp;<br/> "#SB827 is political suicide because it gives opponents and Republicans ample reason to tar this bill and #smartgrowth as a wholesale attack on neighborhood character, democratic local decisionmaking and quality of life."<br/> &nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;


== References ==
== References ==
Line 310: Line 299:
*Elkind, Ethan. "[http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/ KPCC Radio Discussion On SB 827: The Homeowner Backlash]." 5 Jan 2018.&nbsp;[http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/ http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/].<br/> [blog post, links to archived radio show].&nbsp;<br/> &nbsp;
*Elkind, Ethan. "[http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/ KPCC Radio Discussion On SB 827: The Homeowner Backlash]." 5 Jan 2018.&nbsp;[http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/ http://www.ethanelkind.com/kpcc-radio-discussion-on-sb-827-the-homeowner-backlash/].<br/> [blog post, links to archived radio show].&nbsp;<br/> &nbsp;
*Elkind, Ethan. "[http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/ Mitigating Displacement Of Low-Income Renters From New Transit-Oriented Housing]." January 9, 2018.<br/> [http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/ http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/].<br/> &nbsp;
*Elkind, Ethan. "[http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/ Mitigating Displacement Of Low-Income Renters From New Transit-Oriented Housing]." January 9, 2018.<br/> [http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/ http://www.ethanelkind.com/mitigating-displacement-of-low-income-renters-from-new-transit-oriented-housing/].<br/> &nbsp;
*Goodman, Damian. "[http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la SB 827 Is a Declaration of War on South LA]."&nbsp;''Crenshaw Subway&nbsp;Coalition&nbsp;''blog, 5 Jan 2018. [http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la. http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la.&nbsp;]<br/> &nbsp; &nbsp;''"'SB 827 would usurp all of the recent South LA's community plan updates - those years of conversations, workshops and hearings that we engaged in - to replace it with a vision concocted by a pro-gentrification, pro-displacement, real estate industry puppet in Sacramento who goes by the name of Scott Weiner.<br/> &nbsp; &nbsp;''Scott Weiner is to gentrifiers, what Donald Trump is to racists."'<br/> &nbsp;
*Goodmon, Damian. "[http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la SB 827 Is a Declaration of War on South LA]."&nbsp;''Crenshaw Subway&nbsp;Coalition&nbsp;''blog, 5 Jan 2018. [http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la. http://www.crenshawsubway.org/sb_827_must_be_stopped_to_protect_south_la.&nbsp;]<br/> &nbsp; &nbsp;''"'SB 827 would usurp all of the recent South LA's community plan updates - those years of conversations, workshops and hearings that we engaged in - to replace it with a vision concocted by a pro-gentrification, pro-displacement, real estate industry puppet in Sacramento who goes by the name of Scott Weiner.<br/> &nbsp; &nbsp;''Scott Weiner is to gentrifiers, what Donald Trump is to racists."'<br/> &nbsp;
*Grabar, Henry. "[https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html California Bill Would Allow Unrestricted Housing by Transit, Solve State Housing Crisis.]" 5 Jan 2018. [https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html].<br/> ''"At first glance, the bill is too radical to pass; California homeowners would revolt, or at least use their remaining local power to shut down a whole lot of bus routes. At least one advocate for equitable development in South L.A. has compared the bill to Andrew Jackson’s Indian Removal Act. Like most attempts to build more housing, it will likely be crushed between homeowners seeking to preserve property values and renters fearful of the resultant tear-downs and evictions.''<br/> ''&nbsp; &nbsp; "Wiener’s transit-oriented development bill, if it passed, would have the most radical impact of any California law since Prop 13, the 1978 resolution that permanently lowered the state’s property taxes (and dealt a blow to state finances that continues to this day). But even if it doesn’t, it puts some smaller good ideas on the table. If anyone were in a position to get some part of this passed, it would be California Gov. Jerry Brown, who is in the final year of his well-received second stint in charge of the country’s most populous state."''<br/> &nbsp;
*Grabar, Henry. "[https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html California Bill Would Allow Unrestricted Housing by Transit, Solve State Housing Crisis.]" 5 Jan 2018. [https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html https://slate.com/business/2018/01/california-bill-sb827-residential-zoning-transit-awesome.html].<br/> ''"At first glance, the bill is too radical to pass; California homeowners would revolt, or at least use their remaining local power to shut down a whole lot of bus routes. At least one advocate for equitable development in South L.A. has compared the bill to Andrew Jackson’s Indian Removal Act. Like most attempts to build more housing, it will likely be crushed between homeowners seeking to preserve property values and renters fearful of the resultant tear-downs and evictions.''<br/> ''&nbsp; &nbsp; "Wiener’s transit-oriented development bill, if it passed, would have the most radical impact of any California law since Prop 13, the 1978 resolution that permanently lowered the state’s property taxes (and dealt a blow to state finances that continues to this day). But even if it doesn’t, it puts some smaller good ideas on the table. If anyone were in a position to get some part of this passed, it would be California Gov. Jerry Brown, who is in the final year of his well-received second stint in charge of the country’s most populous state."''<br/> &nbsp;
*KPCC. "[https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/ New CA bill calling for denser, taller housing near transit could change the face of LA.]" 5 Jan 2018.&nbsp;[https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/ https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/].<br/> Guests:<br/> Ethan Elkind, director of the climate program at the Center for Law, Energy & the Environment, a joint venture of UCLA and UC Berkeley.<br/> Paul Koretz, City of Los Angeles councilmember representing the 5th District, which includes communities on the westside of L.A.<br/> Mark Ryavec, president of the Venice Stakeholders Association.<br/> <br/> Koretz:&nbsp;''“You could end up with a Dubai around each transit stop.”''<br/> <br/> Ryavec: ''"This could cause the Miamization of Venice Beach."&nbsp;<br/> "The bill is using a sledgehammer to fix a piano."<br/> Suggests restoring cities' ability to do parcelization (parcel assembly), as done formerly under Redevelopment Agencies.&nbsp;<br/> Suggest the bill be scaled back to applying only to San Francisco.&nbsp;''<br/> &nbsp;
*KPCC. "[https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/ New CA bill calling for denser, taller housing near transit could change the face of LA.]" 5 Jan 2018.&nbsp;[https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/ https://www.scpr.org/programs/airtalk/2018/01/05/61045/new-ca-bill-calling-for-denser-taller-housing-near/].<br/> Guests:<br/> Ethan Elkind, director of the climate program at the Center for Law, Energy & the Environment, a joint venture of UCLA and UC Berkeley.<br/> Paul Koretz, City of Los Angeles councilmember representing the 5th District, which includes communities on the westside of L.A.<br/> Mark Ryavec, president of the Venice Stakeholders Association.<br/> <br/> Koretz:&nbsp;''“You could end up with a Dubai around each transit stop.”''<br/> <br/> Ryavec: ''"This could cause the Miamization of Venice Beach."&nbsp;<br/> "The bill is using a sledgehammer to fix a piano."<br/> Suggests restoring cities' ability to do parcelization (parcel assembly), as done formerly under Redevelopment Agencies.&nbsp;<br/> Suggest the bill be scaled back to applying only to San Francisco.&nbsp;''<br/> &nbsp;